Fish It! Tier List
Ranked by catch chance: the top 10% are S tier, the next 15% A, then B, C and D. Updated 2026-10-06.
How the Fish It! tier list works
Every item is ranked by its catch chance: how rare it is to catch (1 in N). The top 10% are S tier, the next 15% A, the next 20% B, the next 25% C and the rest D. That keeps the list objective: an item only changes tier when its catch chance changes, not because of anyone's opinion.
280 items are ranked, last updated on October 6, 2026.
Every tier at a glance
- S tier: 28 items, from 1 in 900K to 1 in 5M.
- A tier: 42 items, from 1 in 25K to 1 in 800K.
- B tier: 56 items, from 1 in 1K to 1 in 25K.
- C tier: 70 items, from 1 in 55 to 1 in 1K.
- D tier: 84 items, from 1 in 2 to 1 in 55.
S tier Fish It! items
The best items right now are Bloodmoon Whale, Elshark Gran Maja, Megalodon, 1x1x1x1 Comet Shark, ElRetro Gran Maja, Icebreaker Whale and 22 more. S tier is all Secret items.
Just below, the A tier starts with Giant Squid, Kraken, Mosasaur Shark, Queen Crab: often better value if an S tier item is out of reach.
| # | Item | Catch chance |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bloodmoon WhaleSecret | 1 in 5M |
| 2 | Elshark Gran MajaSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 3 | MegalodonSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 4 | 1x1x1x1 Comet SharkSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 5 | ElRetro Gran MajaSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 6 | Icebreaker WhaleSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 7 | Strawberry Choc MegalodonSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 8 | Zombie MegalodonSecret | 1 in 4M |
| 9 | 1 in 3.5M | |
| 10 | Ancient Lochness MonsterSecret | 1 in 3M |
Catch chance as of October 6, 2026. Updated with every data refresh.
Fish It! items by rarity
Rarity and tier are not the same thing: the tier comes from catch chance, and some items rank higher or lower than their rarity suggests.
| Rarity | Items | Lowest catch chance | Highest catch chance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common | 43 | 1 in 2 | 1 in 40 |
| Uncommon | 65 | 1 in 50 | 1 in 200 |
| Rare | 42 | 1 in 250 | 1 in 800 |
| Epic | 31 | 1 in 1K | 1 in 5.5K |
| Legendary | 31 | 1 in 5K | 1 in 30K |
| Mythic | 25 | 1 in 50K | 1 in 245K |
| Secret | 43 | 1 in 250K | 1 in 5M |
Tier list or value list?
The tier list groups items so you can see at a glance which are top picks. For exact numbers, search and filters, use the Fish It! value list.
More Fish It! questions
What is the best item in Fish It!?
Bloodmoon Whale, with 1 in 5M. It tops the S tier.
How many items are S tier in Fish It!?
28 of 280: the top 10% by catch chance.
Is the Fish It! tier list based on opinion?
No. It ranks every item by its catch chance and splits them by rank, so it only changes when the data does. Last updated October 6, 2026.
What is the difference between S tier and A tier?
S tier is the top 10% of items by catch chance; A tier is the next 15%. Right now S tier starts at 1 in 900K and A tier at 1 in 25K.